COAIM BLOG
(latest news,
updates, opinions,
etc.)

COAIM HOME

CO AIM
principles
councils
history
photos
in the media

LATEST NEWS
community
upcoming events
urgent issues

MEDIA
alternative
indigenous
mainstream

RESOURCES
educational
legal
perspectives
links

STRUGGLES
native struggles

 

AN OPEN LETTER TO THE AMERICAN INDIAN COMMUNITY 
OF DENVER ON THE OCCASION OF THE 
VISIT OF POPE JOHN PAUL II 
AUGUST 4, 1993

Next week, Pope John Paul II will be visiting Denver to celebrate the Roman Catholic Church's "World Youth Day." As American Indians we are taught to respect all spiritual beliefs, and to respect the spiritual leaders who represent those belief systems. In that regard, all due deference should be accorded the Pope in the spiritual aspects of his visit to Denver. The American Indian Movement of Colorado believes that everyone has the right to follow his/her own spiritual conscience. We are not in the business of dictating a person's religious affiliation or conviction. As an indigenous liberation movement, we believe that our traditional spiritual ways allow us an understanding of life in this part of the world that no other spirituality can offer. We are committed to the practice, maintenance and defense of our traditional indigenous ceremonies and beliefs. Our commitment, however, also requires that we respect other spiritual beliefs, and we condemn all religious and spiritual bigotry.

It should be remembered, however, that the Pope is not only a spiritual leader. He is a political head of state, of the Vatican, that has its own domestic and foreign policy, that has diplomatic relations with other governments and that has representation in the United Nations. The Pope is also, in effect, the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of a massive economic enterprise, with financial and real estate holdings around the world amounting to hundreds of billions of dollars. The impact of these two areas of papal power on American Indian peoples has been enormous, often enormously negative.

For those American Indians who would use an audience with the Pope to press serious Indian issues over which the Pope has some control, or for those who are sincere in their Catholicism, and who seek greater spiritual awareness through the Pope's visit, we respect your efforts. For others of you, who have no particular understanding of the Pope, Catholicism and the Church, we ask that before you allow yourselves to be used as props for the Pope's visit, that you consider what your participation will mean for you and for future generations of American Indian people throughout the Americas. The world is always seeking to exploit us for our dancing, singing, art, or cuisine, but when we ask them to take us or our issues of land rights or treaty rights or religious freedom seriously, we are no longer entertaining to them.

The Pope, and the Church, in their political, legal and economic roles have been, and continue to be, the source of great suffering and oppression for indigenous peoples around the world. The Church was at the forefront of the colonization of the Americas, and the missionaries sent by the Church not only sought to destroy our indigenous ways of life, but they have left our communities with a legacy of psychological and physical destruction that remains unhealed. The Church has never cared about American Indians, except to satisfy its own needs and goals. We hope that you will remember that during this next week. We hope that you will consider that when they ask you to entertain them or to pose for a photo with the Pope as evidence of how nice the Church is to Indians, and how good relations are between the Church and Indian people.

  • Right now, as you are reading this, the Vatican is a partner in a project that is destroying a mountain, Dzil Nchaa si an(Mt. Graham), that is sacred to the San Carlos Apache in Arizona; Through this project, known as the Mt. Graham International Observatory, the Catholic Church unilaterally determined that Dzil Nchaa si an was not sacred to the Apache, and it has denied access to the mountain by the Apaches for their traditional ceremonies. Father George Coyne, the head of the Vatican Observatory, said that the Apache respect for the mountain and the Apache opposition to the project represents "a kind of religiosity to which I cannot subscribe, and which must be suppressed with all the force we can muster." For further information on this continuing destruction of Indian peoples, contact Ola Cassadore Davis, Apache Survival Coalition, Box 1237, San Carlos, AZ 85550, (602) 294-1863.
  • The Pope and the Roman Catholic Church declared 1993 to be a year to Celebrate 500 Years of Evangelization of the Americas. What does that mean? It means that they are celebrating the 500 year process of the systematic destruction of Indian societies, cultures and spiritual beliefs, and their replacement with European institutions. Indian spirituality does not have missionaries. We do not tell people that we are God's chosen people and if they do not believe our "truth" then they will be damned to hell forever. Nor do we travel around the world, as the Franciscans, Dominicans and Jesuits did, accompanying invading European armies, and slaughtering hundreds of thousands of Indian people because they would not convert to Catholicism. We do not kidnap children from their families and physically and psychological abuse them, and indoctrinate them in schools to forget their families and their nations. What exactly is the Church celebrating in its 500 years of evangelization, and do you want to be any part of it?
  • Finally, in his capacity as a legal and political leader, the Pope historically issued legal pronouncements known as Papal Bulls. In the Papal Bull, lnter Caetera of May 3, 1493, Pope Alexander VI, effectively granted the world to Spain to overthrow "barbarous [Indian] nations" so that the "heathen could be drawn to embrace the Catholic faith and be trained in good morals." This Papal Bull, and a few others that followed, formed the legal and political foundation for the stealing of the Americas from our indigenous nations and the slaughter of our ancestors who would not Convert to christianity. The Catholic Church has never rescinded or withdrawn these Bulls, and the church has never apologized for its important role in the theft and destruction of our lands. Indian law today continues to be constructed on the horrible principles of this law.

The list of abuses and wrongs committed against Indian peoples by the Pope and his Church could go on and on. These are three specific and ongoing reasons why Colorado AIM believes that Indian people should not participate in the Pope's activities. Each one of these issues has been raised with the Vatican. Each time, the Church has turned a deaf ear. The Church has used and abused Indians for 500 years, do not allow it to continue, please. Instead, demand that the Pope do three things immediately to begin the long, essential process of reconciliation with Indian peoples:

  1. Immediately withdraw Vatican support and participation in the Mount Graham International Observatory project. Recognize the sacredness of Dzil Nchaa si sn to the Apache people, and respect their right to practice their spirituality in their traditional places.
  2. Rescind the "Celebration of 500 Years of Evangelization of the Americas." Recognize and apologize for the pain and suffering caused by missionaries working in collusion with governments and the military in destroying American Indian nations.
  3. Rescind end renounce the Papal Bull lnter Caetera, and admit that the Pope never possessed the authority to divide or distribute Indigenous peoples' territories.
 

© 2004-2005 Colorado AIM      Contact us at denveraim@coloradoaim.org or 303-832-2544